Peer-to-Peer Review Preparation: What to Have Ready Before the Call | ResolveRCM

Create your account — choose a paid plan when ready See a real appeal packet

Home / Insights / Peer-to-Peer Review Preparation: What to Have Ready Before the Call

Process & Education

Peer-to-Peer Review Preparation: What to Have Ready Before the Call

How to prepare for a peer-to-peer review call with a payer's medical director, and what documentation to have ready before the call happens.

Published October 26, 2026

Why Peer-to-Peer Calls Are Different From Written Appeals

A peer-to-peer review is a direct conversation, usually between the treating provider (or a designated physician) and the payer's reviewing physician, and it moves faster and less predictably than a written appeal. Being under-prepared for the live, conversational format is one of the most common reasons a peer-to-peer call underperforms relative to the strength of the underlying clinical case.

What to Have in Front of the Provider During the Call

At minimum: the specific denial reason and code, the payer's stated coverage policy or criteria for the service (so the provider can speak directly to it rather than generally), a concise clinical summary highlighting the key facts supporting necessity, and any relevant test results or prior treatment history readily accessible — not buried in a full chart the provider has to search during the call.

Preparing the Provider, Not Just the Paperwork

Providers who haven't done many peer-to-peer calls sometimes under-prepare for the conversational, sometimes adversarial tone these calls can take. A brief pre-call briefing — covering what the payer's specific stated objection is, and the key one or two points that most directly address it — tends to produce a more focused, effective call than the provider going in cold with only general familiarity with the case.

Documenting the Call Afterward

Regardless of outcome, documenting what was discussed and any commitments made during the call — in writing, promptly afterward — protects the practice if the payer's stated decision doesn't match what comes through in the follow-up determination.

ResolveRCM generates a concise peer-to-peer prep summary alongside every appeal packet, so providers walk into the call ready. Learn more.

Share this article

LinkedIn Facebook X

Why this matters

Respond to denials faster with structured documentation.

ResolveRCM builds professional, payer-ready appeal packets in minutes — so your team appeals more and writes off less.